A Squarespace site that could not track ads, rebuilt on WordPress
SUP Express · Destin, FL

Paddle-board and kayak rentals on the Emerald Coast moved off Squarespace to a WordPress site with a real booking system and working ad tracking.
The situation
The owner's old design was fine. The platform was the problem. Squarespace would not let Google Ads track conversions, so there was no way to tell whether ad money produced a rental. Many customers were booking through a third-party channel that added fees, and he told some callers to cancel and book direct. A newer competitor was taking customers, and the off-season could bring a month with almost no online reservations. He also did not know his domains were registered with the previous owner.
What we did
- Showed him a one-page mockup before the build, so he could react to a real design instead of a description.
- Rebuilt the site on WordPress and Elementor with rentals and rates up front, plus shop and blog templates for later.
- Worked with FareHarbor's team so their booking code went onto the site, and walked him through the Stripe check that was holding their setup.
- Helped him get three domains moved out of the previous owner's GoDaddy account, so the new site could go live on his own name.
- Launched in May 2025 with Google Analytics, Tag Manager and Search Console connected, the shop held behind a coming-soon page until his inventory was ready, and weekly site reports after that.
What changed
He now has a site he controls, direct booking through FareHarbor, and ad tracking that Squarespace had blocked. Search clicks rose through the first summer, then followed the beach season down, and each month since has been below the same month a year earlier, so we are not claiming a traffic win. We also have no booking or revenue numbers from FareHarbor, so this is a platform and control story rather than a results story. He hired us again the same summer for a second site, for his food truck.
Before and after
